The Hidden Drag on Global ETFs: Overexposure to US Markets

MSCI World ETF US4642863926

A cornerstone of many investment portfolios is facing significant headwinds. While the iShares MSCI World ETF (URTH) has posted modest gains since the start of the year, a powerful reallocation of capital is unfolding beneath the surface. Market participants are engaged in what analysts term a "Great Rotation," moving funds away from expensive US equities and toward international opportunities. This trend poses a particular challenge for this popular fund, given its substantial concentration in American stocks. The critical question for investors is whether this structural bias will lead to a prolonged period of underperformance relative to global peers.

Despite its "World" moniker, the fund's composition tells a different story. With more than 70% of its holdings in US companies, its performance is more closely tied to Wall Street than to a genuinely global basket of equities. This heavy tilt creates a pronounced concentration risk, especially at the top of its holdings. Three technology behemoths—Nvidia, Apple, and Microsoft—collectively account for approximately 14% of the entire portfolio. Furthermore, the technology sector's overall weighting of 34% means the ETF is exceptionally vulnerable to interest rate concerns and valuation anxieties centered on the US market. Meanwhile, sectors currently benefiting from the market's rotational shift, such as energy and financials, are notably underrepresented in the fund.

Valuation Gaps Fuel a Capital Exodus

The driving force behind this shift is a stark divergence in market valuations, which has become a dominant theme in early 2026. The US market, as represented by the S&P 500, is trading at a historically high price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 27.8. In contrast, international markets tracked by the MSCI EAFE index offer a far more moderate P/E of 19.5. This significant discrepancy is now triggering substantial capital movements. Recent data indicates that nearly $6 billion flowed into emerging market ETFs in January alone—capital that is increasingly being withdrawn from US-focused investments. Caught in this crosscurrent, the iShares MSCI World ETF reaps minimal benefit from the international rally while bearing the full burden of elevated US valuations.

The Cost of a US Anchor

A superficial glance at the fund's returns might suggest solid performance. On a year-to-date basis as of January 22, it shows a gain of 22.9%. However, a comparative analysis reveals the substantial opportunity cost of its US-heavy approach. Over the same period, ETFs that specifically exclude US equities surged by 35.3%, and certain international momentum strategies soared by 40%. The US market, acting as a drag, has prevented investors in this global ETF from fully participating in the worldwide market advance.

The outlook for the first quarter of 2026 remains tense for stakeholders. Should the valuation gap narrow via a correction in US technology giants, this ETF would be disproportionately affected. Upcoming quarterly earnings reports from Apple and Nvidia will be pivotal. Disappointing results from these portfolio heavyweights could accelerate the outflow of capital from US-centric products, placing additional downward pressure on the fund's price.

@ boerse-global.de | US4642863926 THE