CAR Group Stock: Quiet ASX Winner US Investors Are Missing

CAR Group Ltd just posted fresh numbers and raised guidance again, yet most US investors still ignore this profitable auto?marketplace operator. Here’s what your portfolio might be missing — and how the risk/reward now stacks up.

Bottom line up front: CAR Group Ltd, the Australian-listed parent of Carsales.com, keeps putting up double?digit earnings growth from online auto classifieds while staying largely under the radar in the US. If you own global consumer tech, or you hunt for durable compounders that aren’t already crowded trades on the NYSE or Nasdaq, this is a name you should at least have on your watchlist.

You’re looking at a business with high margins, recurring dealer subscriptions, and growing exposure to the US used?car and data market via its stake in Trader Interactive — but also currency risk, limited liquidity for US investors, and no SEC listing. Your call is whether the growth runway and cash generation justify those frictions right now. What investors need to know now…

Analysis: Behind the Price Action

CAR Group Ltd (often still referred to by its legacy brand Carsales.com) trades on the Australian Securities Exchange under ticker CAR. It operates leading online automotive marketplaces and data services across Australia, North America, Latin America and parts of Asia, monetizing both dealer subscriptions and consumer listings.

Over the past year, the stock has generally outperformed the broader Australian market, supported by strong demand for used vehicles, digitization of car buying, and operating leverage in its marketplace model. While the exact live share price moves in the last 24–48 hours depend on your data source, the trend around the latest earnings print has been: solid numbers, modest multiple, limited hype — especially from US investors.

Recent company disclosures and coverage from outlets such as Reuters, Bloomberg and local Australian brokers highlight a familiar pattern:

• Revenue and EBITDA growth powered by price increases, higher dealer penetration and improved monetization of premium listings and data products.
• International expansion (notably Trader Interactive in the US and Webmotors in Brazil) contributing a rising share of group earnings.
• Healthy balance sheet, with strong free cash flow supporting dividends and selective M&A.

Here’s a high?level snapshot of what typically matters to investors right now (values are indicative categories only — check your broker or data provider for live figures):

Metric	Comment	Why it matters for US investors
Primary listing	ASX (ticker: CAR), quoted in AUD	No direct US listing; you access via international brokerage or ASX access products.
Business model	Online auto marketplaces & data (Australia, US, Brazil, Asia)	Comparable to US names like Autotrader/Cars.com, but with stronger positions in some overseas markets.
Growth profile	Double?digit earnings growth in recent years	Fits a global growth or Internet/marketplace sleeve without adding US single?country risk.
Profitability	High EBITDA margins, asset?light	Marketplace economics can compound over time, attractive in a higher?rate world that punishes unprofitable tech.
US connection	Major interest in Trader Interactive (US commercial & recreational vehicle marketplaces)	Indirect exposure to the US vehicle and equipment ecosystem, including cyclical trends in trucking, powersports, and RVs.
Currency	Reports in AUD, with rising USD and BRL earnings exposure	Your returns, in USD, will swing with FX; AUD weakness can either boost translated returns or erode them, depending on entry point.

Why this matters for a US?centric portfolio

For US investors who already own mega?cap US tech and consumer platforms, CAR Group offers a different angle on the same structural theme: the migration of high?ticket, information?heavy purchases to digital marketplaces. Instead of ad?driven social media or cloud software, you get recurring dealer subscriptions and upgrade fees to list and promote vehicles.

That matters if you’re trying to diversify away from highly correlated US growth names without giving up on secular trends. CAR’s revenue mix — Australia, North America, Latin America — could reduce home?country concentration risk, even as it adds FX and regulatory complexity.

The stock is typically valued at a premium to traditional classified businesses, but at a discount to some high?flying US software and marketplace names, reflecting its combination of mature Australian operations and higher?growth international assets. For a US?dollar?based investor, the calculus becomes: Is the quality and visibility of cash flows enough to justify navigating an offshore listing and FX swings?

Macro & sector backdrop

Two forces are especially important for CAR Group’s near? to medium?term trajectory:

• Used?car cycle: After pandemic?era spikes in US and global used?car prices, normalization has been underway. For CAR, unit volumes matter more than pricing, but dealer profitability and inventory turnover drive ad and subscription budgets.
• Interest rates & auto credit: Higher rates can pressure auto financing and reduce consumer willingness to upgrade vehicles, but they also incentivize buyers to shop more carefully, which tends to favor well?known online marketplaces over fragmented offline channels.

In the US, platforms like Carvana and Cars.com offer more direct equity plays on used?car transaction volumes and financing spreads. CAR Group is different: it tends to be less exposed to inventory risk and more exposed to advertising and data budgets. That can smooth earnings through cycles but doesn’t make the company immune if dealers pull back on marketing.

Correlation with US indices

While exact correlations fluctuate over time, CAR Group’s stock generally behaves more like a growth?tilted consumer Internet name than a traditional cyclical auto stock. Historically, it shows:

• Some positive correlation with Nasdaq?100 and global growth indices due to its digital marketplace profile.
• Less sensitivity to direct US macro data releases than domestic US tech, because its earnings are driven largely by Australian and Brazilian car markets plus its US Trader Interactive exposure.

If you’re building a globally diversified growth sleeve, CAR can act as a satellite holding that reduces pure US factor exposure while still riding the structural shift to online vehicle buying and data?driven dealer tools.

What the Pros Say (Price Targets)

Recent broker research (from Australian and global houses referenced by platforms like MarketWatch, Yahoo Finance, and local Australian broker notes) points to a predominantly positive institutional stance on CAR Group:

• Consensus rating: Generally clustered around "Buy" or "Outperform" territory, with only a minority of brokers at "Hold."
• Price targets: Most published 12?month targets sit modestly above the current market price, implying mid?single?digit to low?double?digit upside, depending on your chosen data source and live price.
• Key bull arguments: Strong competitive moat in Australia, scalable tech platform, and value?accretive international portfolio, particularly in the US and Brazil.
• Key bear arguments: Elevated valuation relative to local peers, cyclicality in auto markets, integration and execution risk in offshore assets, and FX volatility versus AUD and USD.

In essence, professional analysts see CAR Group as a high?quality compounder rather than a short?term trade. They tend to focus on:

• Sustained double?digit EPS growth through monetization and operating leverage.
• The pace of margin improvement in international businesses versus the more mature Australian operation.
• Management’s capital allocation — particularly how much free cash flow goes to dividends, buybacks, or M&A.

For a US retail investor, one practical constraint is coverage visibility. CAR Group is widely followed in Australia, but less so by big US retail broker platforms. That can occasionally create a knowledge gap — and, for some, an opportunity — if the company delivers positive surprises that aren’t immediately priced in by a predominantly local shareholder base.

How to think about valuation versus US peers

When US investors screen CAR Group against familiar names, the closest conceptual peers are:

• Cars.com (CARS) and Cox Automotive/Autotrader on the US auto classifieds side.
• "Asset?light" marketplace and classified businesses like Rightmove (UK property) or REA Group (Australian property, another classifieds leader).

While the exact multiples change with every tick, CAR typically trades on:

• A valuation above mature, slower?growth classifieds names, reflecting growth and international optionality.
• A valuation below the highest?multiple US SaaS and marketplace stocks that are still burning cash.

If your US holdings skew heavily toward richly valued growth, CAR might look relatively reasonable; if you anchor on traditional value metrics like single?digit EV/EBIT or low P/E, it may feel expensive. The trade?off is between paying for durable network effects today versus waiting for a cheaper entry that may or may not arrive outside a broader market correction.

Key risks US investors should stress?test

• FX and cross?border complexity: Your returns are in USD, the stock is in AUD, and underlying earnings include USD and BRL. That’s a multi?currency puzzle.
• Liquidity: As an ASX?listed name, daily turnover is healthy for local institutions but can be thin relative to large US tech names, especially in US trading hours via cross?border platforms.
• Regulatory and competitive shifts: Any changes in auto advertising practices, data privacy rules, or new marketplace entrants in key geographies could pressure growth or margins.
• Cyclicality: While more resilient than pure auto manufacturers, CAR is not immune to deep recessions that hit dealer marketing budgets.

None of these are deal?breakers by themselves, but they argue for sizing discipline. For most US?based investors, CAR Group will make more sense as a small satellite within an international or thematic sleeve, not as a core holding.

Bottom line for US readers: CAR Group Ltd is not a meme stock or a WallStreetBets darling. It’s a steadily growing, cash?generative marketplace business sitting just off the typical US radar. If you’re willing to do the extra work on FX, offshore access, and local disclosure, it may deserve a spot on your watchlist as a differentiated play on the digitization of auto buying worldwide.

Anzeige

Hol dir den Wissensvorsprung der Profis.

Seit 2005 liefert der Börsenbrief trading-notes verlässliche Trading-Empfehlungen – dreimal die Woche, direkt in dein Postfach.
100% kostenlos. 100% Expertenwissen. Trage einfach deine E-Mail Adresse ein und verpasse ab heute keine Top-Chance mehr.
Jetzt abonnieren.