Air Products Shares Face Investor Skepticism Over Strategic Shift

Air Products US0091581068

Shares of industrial gases giant Air Products have come under significant selling pressure, despite the company reporting solid financial performance. The catalyst for the decline was not weak earnings, but rather the market's cautious reception to a newly announced strategic partnership and ongoing governance concerns.

The downturn began on Monday, December 8, when Air Products disclosed it was in advanced negotiations with Norwegian fertilizer producer Yara International. The proposed collaboration centers on two major low-emission ammonia production projects: one in Louisiana, USA, and another linked to the NEOM Green Hydrogen initiative in Saudi Arabia. While these ventures align the core business with the energy transition, investor reaction was decisively negative. The stock plunged as much as 10.6% that day, hitting a new 52-week low.

Market experts point to a lack of detailed information as a primary driver of the skepticism. With no final agreement in place, shareholders are apprehensive about potential risks, project delays, and the substantial capital commitment required for the multi-billion dollar Louisiana endeavor. This uncertainty was compounded by subsequent analyst adjustments. Several major firms, including UBS, Deutsche Bank, and Jefferies, lowered their price targets for the equity in the following days, even as some maintained an overall positive rating on the company.

Governance Questions Add to the Mix

Further clouding the investment thesis is pressure from activist investors. Hedge fund Mantle Ridge has publicly called for a restructuring of the board of directors and a change in corporate leadership. This challenge contributes to a broader sense of instability regarding the company's strategic direction, which is already under scrutiny following the appointment of a new CEO in February 2025.

This recent volatility presents a stark contrast to the firm's latest operational results. For fiscal year 2025, Air Products reported an adjusted earnings per share of $12.03, surpassing its own guidance. However, these robust figures, released in November, are currently being overshadowed by strategic and governance-related doubts.

The Path Forward Hinges on Clarity

The future trajectory of the stock now depends on clear project milestones. A final investment decision for the Louisiana project is targeted for mid-2026, with completion planned for 2030. A definitive marketing agreement for the NEOM project is expected to follow in the first half of 2026. These concrete steps will be crucial for management to demonstrate the financial and operational viability of these large-scale ventures to shareholders. Until then, the equity is likely to remain volatile as debates over the company's strategic path continue.